
In
this post I asked why there appeared to be one rule for a white man in england running a farm and keeping a pet cow for his daughter and another for a group of people in west wales keeping a pet cow as a god.
As you will recall, even the copious volumes of whitewash applied to the Avian Flu Incident on Bernard Matthew's farm failed miserably to stop official reports on the affair pointing out the ease by which THAT disease could be vectored between animals at the site given the state of repair of the place. So you won't be surprised to hear that cattle farmers in west wales are rightly concerned for the health of their herds, and the health of their business, both of which are being put at risk by the shilly-shallying demonstrated by the Welsh Assembly Hot Air Talking Pit.
And it does not help that the Minister for The Rural Affairs Of Little England (well, what else can you call him now that nationwide control of food safety issues has been sacrificed on the pagan altar of devolution) has emulated pontius pilate by making
this statement on his ministerial blog page.
While this is the attitude of the Mother Of Parliaments to a matter that threatens the health of the nation then May Your God Help You.
Seeking enlightenment on this matter, I took the opportunity to follow the request on the Skanda Vale Temple website, and sent an email to the self styled "Welsh Assembly Government" Member with responsibility for Rural Affairs, Jane Davidson.
I wrote to her on the 5th of June. And because this is a matter that affects Human as well as animal health, I wrote to Edwina Hart, the AM with responsibility for Health Matters a few days later.
Here is what I said
Good Morning
As an omnivorous, former christian, and somewhat reluctant constituent of the Welsh Assembly - I would much sooner see it abolished and universal standards of government returned to the whole of the United Kingdom - I wondered if you would spare me a few moments of your time.
I have sat back over the last few weeks utterly amazed that this part of the United Kingdom has descended into a society where appeasement of a religion that worships a cow takes precedence over the execution of measures designed to protect our food chain. I refer of course to the shilly-shallying that the Welsh Assembly has demonstrated over the animal that seems to have been elevated to the status of godhood by a religious community in West Wales.
I see from the Skanda Vale website that they are now putting up the thoughts of "Shambo The Earthly Representative Of Lord Shivas Bull". And I also see that they have placed a link on their website encouraging all who come to it to e-mail you their thoughts on the matter. So I hope you will forgive me for exercising my right as a resident of a constituency in the South East Wales Region to do just that.
I would begin by asking what right a religious community have to demand that an animal be exempted from the public - and animal - health measures that have been in place, and have been imposed on farmers without mercy, often to their financial ruin, for the protection of the food chain as a whole, for as long as I can remember.
Now I must confess a vested interest here.
Out of sheer outrage at the way I and my fellow passengers are treated like cattle of the edible variety every time we have tried to leave the country to go on holiday, and IN NO WAY out of any interest whatsoever in reducing my carbon footprint, I have not FLOWN anywhere for over ten years. I wonder if any of your fellow workers in that hot air pit in Cardiff Bay can say the same. And I recently ploughed the money I would have spent on foreign holidays into the purchase of a static caravan in Pendine. Not a milion miles away from the location of this bunch of cattle worshippers.
As a semi-retired semi-resident of this village community I try hard to support the local economy in the area in which I have purchased my new holiday home. As an omnivore I find one local establishment does a particularly splendid sunday lunch, the raw materials for which include locally raised organic welsh beef. And if anyone wants to fully understand what cattle are SUPPOSED to be used for, send them to me and I'll stand the bill for a plate of Paul's Special Sunday Lunch for them so they can have their eyes opened.
But it seems to me now that a tiny minority of fundamentalist vegans are being allowed to flaunt the rules designed to ensure the ready supply of desease-free meat for my table. They demand that an animal that has tested positive for a debilitating disease that threatens the health of all cattle in the neighbourhood, and therefore threatens the supply of locally produced beef to establishments, and omnivores throughout south west wales, be spared from the ending every other animal with this disease has met.
Now I can understand that the people who consider this animal a god also consider me a heathen destined for the deepest pit of hell for having the audacity to wish to kill and eat their god. I can live with that, not least because I don't believe in their god, or their vision of hell, or anyone else's for that matter anymore. And I, unlike the followers of what are thankfully still mionority religions in the United Kingdom of Great Britain And Northern Ireland, am happy to have my food stunned before it is killed.
I can also see the obvious benefit to the feel-good factor in the people of this country as a whole in allowing these fundamentalist vegans the PRIVILEGE to follow THEIR way of life in this United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. Not least because to deny them that PRIVILEGE puts this country right up there with Saudi Arabia.
However, I believe that when a person legally resident in this country gratefully accepts the privilege accorded to them to follow the tenets of their faith, they must also accept this does not extend to them the right to endanger the health and well being of others, nor does it give them the right to impose upon others the tenets of their faith. So whilst I would support the Hindus of South West Wales being allowed to worship the HEALTHY animals they wish to elevate to GodHood, I strenuously object when those practices deny me and the still overwhelming majority of the population of this country, who practice an omnivorous diet, the right to indulge in the traditional rite of consuming a sunday dinner of roast beef and yorkshire pud.
After all, decades before your government started mucking about with our rights and freedoms, it was the right of anyone to stand in Hyde Park Corner and say what they liked, to whoever they liked, save only for the fact that if what they said incited those assembled to riot, then they went to jail. Directly To Jail. Because I believe the right and freedom of the person standing next to me in the street to swing his fist ends roughly where my nose starts. Something Peter Tatchell recently found out isn't always observed in the countries formerly behind the Iron Curtain.
So, I would in summary like to ask you whether, now that David Milliband has followed the example laid down by Pontius Pilate, you are going to take measures to maintain the disease free state of the cattle herds in west wales, or whether you wish to introduce fundamentalist veganism by the back door by allowing those herds to become infected with Bovine Tuberculosis, thereby destroying the livelihood of a number of welsh farmers raising good quality beef for the table.
yours
John Of Gwent
I didn't expect a reply and true to form neither of these people have had the courage to answer my questions. But Jane Davidson did pass my e-mail to an underling in the 'TB Team' (would that be Tuberculosis, or Tony Blair, I wonder).
And the reply, although it says nothing of substance, and shows that nothing is being done to protect our food chain, does throw some insight into the way the country must now be run with sensitivity to those who wish to peddle their religion of fundamentalist veganism and put those whose businesses depend on the eating of (non-halal) meat out of business. An extreme view ? Well, here's the reply. What do YOU think ?
From: Griffiths, Claire (EPC OCVO)
To: johnofgwent
Sent: Wednesday, June 13, 2007 12:16 PM
Subject: FW: Have You Killed That Cow Yet ? Why Not ?
Dear John Of Gwent
Thank you for your email of 5 June 2007 sent to Jane Davidson AM, Minister for Sustainability and Rural Development about the Skanda Vale TB reactor bullock. I have been asked to respond.
As you may be aware, TB in cattle is an infectious disease that has a significant impact on the health and welfare of the national cattle herd in Wales. It is a disease that is transmissible to people and other mammals, which means it has serious implications beyond the health of cattle.
An animal kept by the Community of the Many Names of God has tested positive for bovine TB. The policy of the Welsh Assembly Government, in common with many other countries, is that cattle which have tested positive for TB should be slaughtered to protect public health and the health of other animals. The Welsh Assembly Government is sensitive to the beliefs of Hindus and of the Community and is continuing to assess all the issues surrounding this very difficult case. There is currently no timetable for the slaughter of the bullock, though the slaughter notice remains in force. We will continue to deal with this matter in as sensitive a way as possible with the Community.
Yours sincerely
TB Team
Office of the Chief Veterinary Officer
So there we have it ladies and gentlemen.
1. An admission that 'Shambo' HAS reacted to the test for bovine TB.
2. An admission that this disease is infectious and can SIGNIFICANTLY AFFECT THE NATIONAL CATTLE HERD (this silly woman of course thinks the disease respects the River Dee and River Severn. As those who had to deal with the Avian Flu outbreak on Bernard Matthew's farm will tell you, bugs don't carry passports and disease doesn't respect immigration control, so Look Out England And Mr Milliband you're at risk too)
3. An admission that the disease IS transmissible to humans and other mammals.
4. And an admission that the people given the responsibility for protecting our health are sitting on their bums, wringing their hands for fear of annoying a tiny minority who call this diseases animal a god.